top of page

PTSD and how may we help.

Writer: Ian Miller
Ian Miller
2 days ago
4 min read

The strongest current view is that PTSD in serving personnel and veterans is treatable, and that specialist psychological therapy should usually be the first choice. Medication can help, but care should also address sleep, pain, alcohol use, relationships and the person’s ability to live meaningfully. The US Department of Veterans Affairs and Department of Defense guidance gives priority to specific therapies that work directly with trauma. PTSD: National Center for PTSD

There is also greater recognition that military trauma can involve guilt, shame, bereavement and betrayal, alongside fear. Someone may be troubled by what happened to them, what they witnessed, what they did, or what they could not prevent. That distinction matters when deciding how to help. PTSD: National Center for PTSD

Which treatments have the strongest evidence?

Three individual therapies receive the strongest recommendation in the VA/DoD guideline:

Treatment

What it involves

Cognitive Processing Therapy — CPT

Examining beliefs left by trauma, such as “It was all my fault”, “I should have saved them” or “Nobody can be trusted”, and developing a more balanced understanding.

Prolonged Exposure — PE

Gradually approaching traumatic memories and safe situations the person has been avoiding, with a trained therapist, to reduce their continuing power.

Eye Movement Desensitisation and Reprocessing — EMDR

Working with traumatic memories while following alternating movements, sounds or taps, as part of a structured therapeutic process.

These treatments aim to reduce the distress and disruption attached to memories; they do not erase what happened. Evidence generally favours them over medication for lasting improvement. The choice should reflect the person’s preferences, circumstances and access to a properly trained therapist. PTSD: National Center for PTSD

Treatment can be emotionally demanding. But it should be explained, agreed and delivered collaboratively. If someone cannot accept one approach, that should open a discussion about alternatives. Other supported options include Written Exposure Therapy and Present-Centred Therapy, which focuses on current difficulties without detailed processing of traumatic memories. PTSD: National Center for PTSD

Where does medication fit?

The best-supported medicines for PTSD are sertraline, paroxetine and venlafaxine. They are reasonable options when someone prefers medication, cannot access suitable therapy, or has other problems such as depression that also need treatment. They can reduce symptoms, although they do not work for everyone. PTSD: National Center for PTSD

There are some important distinctions:

  • Prazosin may help trauma-related nightmares, although it is not recommended as a treatment for PTSD as a whole.

  • Benzodiazepines, such as diazepam and alprazolam, are recommended against for PTSD because they lack established benefit and carry risks including dependence, mental clouding and interference with therapy.

  • Cannabis is also recommended against as a PTSD treatment because convincing evidence of benefit is lacking and there are potential harms.

Anyone already taking prescribed medication should discuss changes with their clinician; benzodiazepines in particular should not be stopped abruptly. PTSD: National Center for PTSD

Military experience needs to be understood

An increasingly influential concept is moral injury: lasting distress after experiences that violate a person’s deeply held values. A veteran may feel, “I do not deserve to be forgiven,” rather than simply, “I am still in danger.”

Moral injury is not itself a psychiatric diagnosis, and it can occur with or without PTSD. Established PTSD therapies can still help when both are present. Researchers are also developing treatments that deal more directly with guilt, responsibility, values and rebuilding a meaningful life. PTSD: National Center for PTSD

A useful treatment relationship therefore needs room for difficult truths. Reassurance alone may feel hollow to someone carrying a particular memory or a profound sense of betrayal.

Sleep and alcohol problems need attention alongside PTSD

Persistent insomnia deserves treatment in its own right. Cognitive Behavioural Therapy for Insomnia — CBT-I has strong evidence and teaches practical ways to restore sleep, rather than relying solely on sleeping tablets. Mental Health

Alcohol or drug problems should not automatically exclude someone from trauma therapy. Current VA guidance supports treating PTSD and substance use problems together: having one condition should not become a barrier to receiving care for the other. PTSD: National Center for PTSD

What about newer treatments?

There is serious research, but the strength of evidence varies:

Approach

Current position

MDMA-assisted therapy

Promising trial results, with important remaining questions about study quality, safety, therapist safeguards and delivery. It remains an emerging approach rather than an established replacement for recommended treatment.

Psilocybin-assisted therapy

Much less direct evidence for PTSD than for some other conditions.

Ketamine

Not recommended for PTSD itself in the VA/DoD guideline; it may have a separate role for treatment-resistant depression.

Brain stimulation, such as rTMS, and stellate ganglion block injections

Under investigation; the VA/DoD guideline found insufficient evidence to recommend for or against them for PTSD.

A promising treatment and a proven treatment are different stages of knowledge. Clinics advertising a rapid “reset” or guaranteed cure go beyond what this evidence establishes. PTSD: National Center for PTSD

What should someone reasonably expect from care?

They should be offered an understandable explanation of their options, a genuine choice where possible, and regular review of whether treatment is helping. Progress should include everyday goals—sleeping better, managing anger, reconnecting with family or being able to leave the house—as well as symptom scores. If one treatment provides too little benefit, the plan should be reconsidered with them. PTSD: National Center for PTSD

There is sound reason for hope, including for people with complicated histories. Current guidance recognises that trauma-focused treatment can help people with complex PTSD and moral injury too. A difficult history does not place someone beyond treatment, and an unsuccessful attempt does not exhaust the available options.


 
 
 

Comments


© 2021.IAN KYDD MILLER. PROUDLY CREATED WITH WIX.COM

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
bottom of page